TY - JOUR JF - maaref-tafsir JO - مطالعات تفسیری VL - 3 IS - 9 PY - 2012 Y1 - 2012/5/01 TI - A comparative study of interpretative methods in conciliating purity and wrong of the prophet Dawood TT - بررسی تطبیقی روش‌های تفسیری فریقین در سازگاری عصمت حضرت داوود× و خطای او N2 - Commentator`s interpretative methods is known as one origin for Shiite and Sunni difference in Quran commentaries. Commentators, when interpreting the verses 22-26 of chapter Suad, differ in conciliating prophet Dawood`s purity and wrong. Surveying Shiite and Sunni`s commentary methods comparatively, the paper has intended to study the origins of commentator`s differences. To do so, some Shiite and Sunni`s commentaries including Shiite commentaries Al-Tebyan, Noor al-Thaqalayn and Al-Mizan and Sunni`s Jami al-Bayan, Mafatih al-Ghaib, Ruh al-Ma'ani and Al-Munir have been studied with regard to the subject. It has been proved that Al-Mizan, taking the method of Quran to Quran commentary and using reasonable and theological proofs and traditions as supporter, has presented the solution best. SP - 57 EP - 80 AU - Harati, Mohammadjavad AU - Moaddab, Sayyed Reza AD - Buali Sina University KW - Comparative commentary KW - interpretative method KW - prophets` purity KW - dawood`s wrong UR - http://tafsir.maaref.ac.ir/article-1-1605-en.html ER -